Stepper Driver L6203 - with or without L6506?

My goal is to drive a 24V Stepper Motor Nema 17 or 23 with SimpleFOC, therefore a driver board with 4 PWM In is needed. And capable of something around 3,5A +/-1. After searching for hours and hours, results are frustrating:

  • L298N galore, but the efficiency is horrible
  • too little Amps
  • total overkill DC drivers, large in size, power and price, 2 needed
  • total overkill in functionality and price (all the ODrive-esque stuff)
  • Step/Dir

Now I’m doing my own, using 2 L6203, the PCB is ready to order prototypes. I did two versions, one with current controler L6506 and one without. Does it make any sense to put the L6506 in between using SimpleFOC? Or is this a stupid idea?

The variant without the L6506 will also have the current sensing ability/resistors on board.

Hey @Tyandriel,

You could use a BLDC driver for this and use HybridStepperMotor class of the library.
This will alllow you to control your stepper without the need for a complicated setup.

The only catch is that maximum speed will be a bit lower for the same voltage.

Actually a mini v2 would work in your case pretty well I think.

Hello @Antun_Skuric !

many thanks for your reply! I definetly will try the Mini, I’ll buy a bunch of them anyway.
In this application, speed actually won´t be an issue at all, Power / Holding Torque is far more important whilst stayin reasonably small (max. NEMA23)

Since the PCB design is finished and the L6203s just arrived, a trial of the driver will also happen. I’ll post the results and maybe the Gerber etc. when/if it’s doing well enough.

finally time to write… the driver board is finished since 2 weeks. It’s working quite nicely (it’s the reference design, no feat by me). Tested @12V with a simple stepper code it delivers way more power than the L298. For prototyping I have a setup with quite tight 3D printed gears, the L298 wasn’t even able to move the gears alone. The L6203 had no problems with that.
With FOC it’s even beefier. It got quite hot in “hold position” without load, but did´t shut down either. But then, current sensing wasn´t used. I´d recommend heat sinks when leaving playground.

+5V is “Enable” and leading to both drivers, by the way.

Gerber files can be provided, incl. BOM, just PM me.

I have 3 PCBs left. If anyone wants them, I’d only want shipping.
Rest of the BOM costs with genuine parts are ~25€/pc without PCB and terminals (just for info, not sold by me).

I’ll try the Mini v2.3 next! Quarter the size, quarter the costs… sounds pretty much like a better solution.